Seeking to comprehend the true situation in Britain and discover ways to address it?
Subscribe to Vicky Spratt's exclusive email list,
The State We’re In
,
where she examines the major challenges influencing the nation. You can subscribe to receive it directly in your email each week, without fail.
here
.
"Should we prioritize golf courses and green belts over council homes?" This was the query raised by the ex-Labour head of Enfield Council, Ergin Erbil, in an Instagram clip recorded at Crews Hill Golf Club in northern London, which was shared on 1 May.
Only a few days later, on 7 May, the Labour party also lost authority over Enfield Council, along with 11 council positions, while the Green Party and Conservative Party each secured five and six seats, resulting in the Conservatives taking full control.
Both the Conservative Party and the Green Party campaigned on a stance against constructing homes within Enfield's green belt, and they also criticized the Labour Government's plan to develop one of its key projects.
“next generation new towns
Here, along with the local council's backing of the mentioned proposal.
What's coming up in this week's newsletter:
-
An exclusive detailed report from Crews Hill and Chase Park in Enfield, one of the
suggested key sites for Labour's new urban developments
-
Reporting from the scene, highlighting how Labour's planning changes have affected local areas, as told by residents themselves.
-
What next for Labour’s
new towns agenda?
Is it possible to proceed without gaining the support and approval of the local population?
This section of Enfield, where rolling
green belt
The hills offer an unobstructed view of London's skyline, a nearby golf course is located beside a railway station that can take travelers to the center of the city in only 41 minutes, and a "golden mile of gardening centers" takes up prime real estate, sparking significant controversy over development plans that have greatly impacted...
Labour’s major planning reforms
and new towns plan.
On last Wednesday, 27 May, Conservative council member Alessandro Georgiou was chosen as head of Enfield's small group of Tory officials.
Georgiou's initial action was writing to the
Minister for Housing and Planning, Matthew Pennycook
to officially rescind the council's backing for government plans to build on land at Crews Hill and other areas within the borough's green belt, aiming to establish a leading "new town." Both the Government and City Hall have referred to it as a "strategic area" for expansion.
According to Labour's proposals, following several discussions, Crews Hill might transform into a new settlement featuring 21,000 residences (with 40 percent required to be low-cost) along with updated facilities such as highways, educational institutions, and medical centers.
In her letter, Georgiou stated that the Conservatives possessed "a clear mandate to safeguard Enfield's green belt" and mentioned that the council's approach has shifted, indicating they will no longer prioritize revitalizing Enfield Town center, but rather concentrate on constructing residences on previously developed land.
During the period leading up to Georgiou's official selection as leader,
The i Paper
went to Crews Hill and talked with locals, shopkeepers, and activists.
Currently, it remains uncertain precisely where the borders of the planned new town will be and which nearby businesses will be affected. Nevertheless, according to Erbil's social media updates, the former Labour-led council had previously indicated that both the golf club and local gardening centers were under consideration for redevelopment.
Due to modifications introduced by Pennycook in the Planning and Infrastructure Act, this might have been possible with enhanced measures
mandatory acquisition order (MAO) regulations
. Additional modifications monitored by Pennycook comprise
changing the classification of low-value green belt areas to "grey belt"
so that it may be advanced for additional residential development and facilities.
In various
interviews
with me,
Pennycook
has clearly stated that, in his opinion, Community Police Officers and gray belt officers play an essential role in providing new homes for young individuals excluded from home ownership, as well as in developing new social housing.
Nevertheless, people from Crews Hill and Enfield have not taken kindly to Erbil's approach on social media or to what they saw as the Government's "failure to communicate".
Located at Thompsons of Crews Hill, within the "golden mile" of nurseries along Cattlegate Road, known throughout London and the surrounding areas for their gardening products, 36-year-old Clare Thompson, who leads this family-owned company employing 70 staff, felt distressed.
Regrettably, the municipal authority has not been very open," she states. "There isn't much certainty regarding these plans [for a new settlement] here, yet we aim to continue expanding our company, and this ambiguity prevents us from doing so.
As the fourth generation of Thompsons employed by the family's namesake company, Clare states, she is concerned about what lies ahead. While she acknowledges the necessity for additional housing in London, she experiences pain and bewilderment regarding what she sees as established local enterprises being singled out by the previous council head.
If this proceeds and they construct where our gardening centers are located, it will create significant disruption—resulting in job losses and the loss of family histories... we advocate for a greener London. There's no reason to eliminate it.
Why hasn’t there been discussion about moving companies elsewhere? I question if she can imagine a scenario where her businesses, along with those on this street, could become part of a fresh community? She agrees it’s possible, yet mentions that such a dialogue hasn’t taken place.
The pathways lined with flowers and bushes at Thompsons are lively, despite being midday on a Wednesday.
A customer, a local gentleman called Mark, approaches me. He asks if we're at Crews Hill to talk about the latest town plans?
A 68-year-old retiree claims he has resided in this region for four decades. Although he is fully conscious of increasing property costs and their implications for his daughter and nephews, he does not back the government's suggested measures.
I've observed that there are two government policies that appear to counteract one another," Mark states. "One aims at fostering businesses and promoting development. This area is truly flourishing and has consistently been so. The other focuses on constructing towns and homes, but if they eliminate these prosperous businesses to make way for housing, it will lead to catastrophe. Therefore, these two approaches conflict with each other.
According to Mark, he backs new housing developments provided they are "meticulously planned."
As we depart from Thompsons, another resident of the area, who prefers to stay unidentified, shares that they overheard Erbil referring to the gardening centers as "run-down" and chose to support the Green Party for the very first time due to being deeply surprised.
The Labour party relies on its fresh towns initiative to meet its highly challenging objective of constructing 1.5 million new residences, alongside fostering economic development. Britain's economic regulator, the
Budget Responsibility Office (BRO)
forecasting an increase of 0.2 percent to GDP by 2029-30 due to Pennycook's planning changes – equivalent to approximately £6.8 billion at current values.
However, in Crews Hill, the government's rhetoric has encountered the rough terrain of real life.
Exactly because Cattlegate Road is small, and since it serves as one of the few major routes in Crews Hill, plus acts as a branch road leading to the M25 highway, it often gets entirely blocked. Residents frequently voice worries over whether it can handle additional housing without realizing that Labour has promised to adopt an "infrastructure-first" strategy for their new developments, suggesting it may soon be expanded or rebuilt.
Labour's confident stance on growth, frequently referred to as
YIMBYism (Yes In My Backyard)
and has seen
Housing Minister Steve Reed shouting "Build Baby Build"
In a nod to the Trump catchphrase "Drill Baby Drill," while donning a red baseball cap (at one gathering where he was seen next to Erbil, who had an identical headwear), he has also come into conflict with locals.
Adjacent to the Thompsons' location, at Three Counties Garden Buildings—a different family-owned enterprise—owner Emma Breeze, who inherited the company from her father when he established it in 1988, is nearly emotional.
We hadn't heard about Crews Hill being looked into for a new town until it was revealed on TV," she said, her eyes filling with tears. "Since then, I've been searching online and trying to figure out where we might relocate...I just can't seem to find anywhere.
Emma states that she is "heartbroken."
This entire situation has left everyone uncertain. We have six employees... we had planned to invest in the company, but those plans are now delayed. I've become somewhat indifferent towards politics lately, but I did vote for the Conservatives in the local election. I hoped they would win because my family business really needs to stay afloat.
Is Emma seen as being a
nimby?
A person who simply responds with "not in my back yard" regarding new housing? That phrase isn’t one she recognizes. "I'm just trying to protect my living and my employees' jobs," she says, still emotional.
Residential property values differ throughout the Enfield borough in London, yet regardless of the metric used, they remain high.
According to the ONS
A standalone house typically averages £1,210,000, a semi-detached property costs around £702,000, a terrace home is approximately £492,000, and an apartment is about £293,000.
The typical salary in this region is
£43,000
, indicating that even if an apartment costs more than six times the typical income, it represents the maximum amount most mortgage lenders would permit a person to loan.
Although Enfield is not the most severely impacted London borough, almost 7,000 individuals are registered on the local authority's housing queue, with families facing an expected wait of over five years for a suitable residence. Additionally, around 3,000 residents in the region are presently without permanent shelter, residing in costly (and occasionally inappropriate) short-term accommodations.
Matt Burn, a regional planning specialist and representative of Better Homes Enfield, joins us to share his frustration with the way the recent town meeting at Crews Hill unfolded.
There is considerable brownfield area available, as well as some greenbelt land that I've brought to the attention of the council—land where development can occur without needing to encroach upon these garden centers, which provide approximately 1,000 roles in AI-resistant positions, or the nearby golf course, designated as an important site for nature conservation," Burn clarifies. "I've conducted research and requested data from the council; there exists a method to achieve optimal outcomes.
Burn, who had been a long-time member of the Labour party up until now, brings up concerns about the party's speech and mentions this as a factor in why he chose to support another candidate during the local elections, although he refuses to reveal whom he actually voted for.
When I witnessed the Housing Secretary moving energetically and declaring, 'Build Baby Build,' I found it utterly foolish," Burn comments. "That's precisely what we don't need. As numerous individuals understand, housing is an extremely complex matter. Addressing it will demand substantial thinking and thorough examination, and performing on stage wearing a red hat isn't what we're looking for.
Matt characterizes the manner in which the council's former Labour government managed communications regarding these alterations as "autocratic."
"The manner in which they withheld information—it's entirely inappropriate. They've damaged the chance for a new community here because of how they managed it," he states, appearing distressed.
Matt also refuses the "nimby" designation.
It's oversimplified and absurd," he states. "This isn't my neighborhood...I've suggested locations for construction right at my front door. It's concerning careful planning and dialogue...I simply don't have time for this yimby/nimby argument.
In this regard, Matt shares with me a document he has prepared, highlighting 10 green belt areas in the region that he believes can support thousands of new residences without disrupting local enterprises or shutting down the golf course. He mentions that he submitted it to the council but hasn’t gotten any reply. This might be because of continuous legal review procedures.
Resistance against new towns is not a recent phenomenon. Following the end of the Second World War, Clement Attlee's Labour administration promised a surge in new construction, leading to the creation of locations such as Stevenage, Basildon, and Corby.
In 1946, as Lewis Silkin, Attlee's minister responsible for urban and rural development, inspected the initial location planned for their newly envisioned towns—Stevenage—the residents of the area, still considered a small settlement at the time, expressed their dissatisfaction by erecting a large sign at the train station that said "SILKINGRAD."
Silkin replied to his unfriendly reception group: "There's no point in your mocking, it will get done."
Matt and I have reached Crews Hill Golf Club, which Erbil mentioned in his Instagram video as having "20 members".
We encounter the manager, David Spring, who mentions that the number is approximately 200 and points around—today is a bright day during school break, and the club is organizing activities for youth. Many of them are young men engaged in play and education together.
The footage from Erbil, along with rumors that have emerged due to the absence of clear details regarding the Government's specific strategies (which will be officially revealed later this year), has led to increased anxiety in this region.
This goes beyond just being a golf course," Spring mentions. "We serve as a central gathering place. We organize numerous events for locals, neighborhood organizations, and municipal groups within our event spaces.
Spring mentions that there is a specific activity taking place during the school break, featuring 100 young golf players as we arrive.
"It's something we aim to encourage as a club, benefiting both the future of sports and golf, as well as our long-standing members," he states, emphasizing its significance during an era where youth spend excessive time online.
Golf equipment is often seen as high-end and costly. A
Junior membership at Crews Hill
approximately £17 per month, along with a reduced daily charge of £20 for younger members.
At the counter, 17-year-old Jack, who resides close by, is handling customer requests. This marks the fourth day of his very first part-time position. How does he, as a young individual who might never afford to purchase a home in his hometown, perceive this new town?
It would truly be unfortunate if it were genuine," he remarks. "New homes are being built in Enfield, and they'll require a neighborhood.
Recent advancements in the region involve a significant renewal project known as Meridian Water, a £6 billion, two-decade-long initiative led by the local authority in Upper Edmonton, located in the southeastern part of the district. This plan aims to construct 10,000 residences adjacent to the Lee Valley Regional Park. Additionally, substantial projects in the vicinity are being developed by large-scale housing developers such as Bellway and Berkeley.
According to Vicki Pite, a former Enfield Labour council member who now works as a local environmental activist, uncertainty about which elements will be part of a potential new town in Crews Hill has led to resistance.
Pite brings me to Botany Bay Farm Shop, located on 76 acres of active agricultural land, just under five minutes away from both the golf club and the train station via a public path that offers views of London.
Such green areas have a cooling impact on London," she states as we gaze toward the skyline. "I think we require them if heat levels continue to increase.
Nevertheless, Pite acknowledges that Crews Hill might be able to support additional homes and facilities provided "thoughtful consideration" is applied.
"The Labour group that has been managing the council around here recently hasn't recognized the crucial function of oversight... they've wasted a majority that was achieved through dedicated effort over several years due to this," she further states.
Matt and Vicki feel sorry for how things have turned out. Both believe that the debate over the plan shouldn't have been framed as an option between environmental areas, the golf course, nearby shops, and residential development. They wish their neighborhood could accommodate all of these elements.
As the day comes to an end, the sun still shines intensely. In inner London, where issues of affordable housing and development problems persist, the area sparkles under the heat, with rising temperatures amplifying emotions in Crews Hill regarding discussions about significant changes planned for their neighborhood—discussions that focus more on talking about the community rather than engaging in meaningful communication about these developments.
In truth, the government's apparent distance could indicate that intricate legal discussions need to take place prior to finalizing any new town developments. A public review regarding the planned New Towns Programme and its ecological effects started on Monday, 23 March, and ended on Tuesday, 19 May. The Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities (DLUHC) is now examining the input gathered and intends to release a reply "at an appropriate time." Additionally, they will be required to carry out environmental evaluations.
While visiting Crews Hill, I questioned locals about their knowledge of these procedures and discussions. All responded with "no."
Latest surveys, carried out specially for me right here at
The i Paper
by Ipsos
It was disclosed that the majority of individuals in Britain believe the Labour party is "performing poorly" regarding housing issues, with limited knowledge of Labour's housing strategies among the broader population.
It is evident that there has been a breakdown in communication among Westminster, Enfield Council, and Crews Hill.
Place-making and involvement with local stakeholders are intended to play a significant role in Labour's New Towns Initiative. Nevertheless, should Crews Hill be selected and resistance continues among locals, shopkeepers, and the council, it may lead to the establishment of a development corporation—a separate public implementation entity—and compulsory acquisition of land to construct a new settlement in this area.
Several elements will now determine the outcome at Crews Hill.
This might serve as a precedent for Labour's updated planning regulations, featuring "grey belt" areas, increased compulsory acquisition (CPO) authority, fewer official stakeholders involved in consultations, and an assumption that new housing developments close to railway stations will be approved. A development agency equipped with CPO capabilities could also be established locally to oversee the progress of this new town.
It will definitely serve as a trial for public sentiment as the Government seeks to advance an extensive construction initiative involving significant new communities throughout England.
When questioned about whether he felt remorse over his social media comments regarding Crews Hill Golf Club after significant setbacks for his party in the local elections, Erbil stated he had "nothing more to say" aside from what he had previously shared "in public."
Erbil, who appeared onstage alongside Housing Secretary Steve Reed sporting a "Build Baby Build" hat during the Labour convention, added: "I recognize why business owners and locals in Crews Hill expressed worries, and these issues must always be heard. However, I urge reporters, activists, and officials to engage not just with individuals who can enjoy a round of golf on a weekday afternoon in Crews Hill, but also with families staying in temporary housing, those dealing with homelessness, youth unable to remain in their neighborhoods due to high costs, and people residing in homes that aren’t suitable for living."
Ever since my re-election, I've already dealt with numerous housing-related cases. Individuals are seeking assistance to get listed on the housing registry, facing difficulties in affording local homes, or residing in severe conditions that can only be called substandard housing. These are the individuals whose perspectives are frequently overlooked in this discussion.
A representative from the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) stated: "Our pioneering nationwide new towns initiative aims to bring back the vision of home ownership for individuals throughout the nation."
Recently, we have discussed the plans with community members and will provide our response at an appropriate time.
When questioned about claims made by locals stating that Housing Minister Steve Reed had never visited Crews Hill, MHCLG remained silent.
Tom Copley, the deputy mayor responsible for housing and community development, stated: "Crews Hill, along with other locations within the borough, present a major chance to create environmentally friendly, top-notch neighborhoods, enhance the availability and accessibility of natural areas and nearby green spaces, and address London's severe housing shortage."
Working together with the Government, we will keep collaborating closely with Enfield councilors to advance developments at Crews Hill, incorporating suggestions for broad engagement with the nearby residents.
Housing crisis watch
The housing shortage in London is becoming more severe. That's quite an achievement, considering it was already dire! Recent figures from the real estate firm JLL indicate that thousands of newly constructed homes (primarily apartments) within the city remain unoccupied.
According to their estimates, the figure might reach up to 22,000 (though I'm still working to confirm this). Several factors could explain why newly built apartments remain unsold, but the main causes are probably a) individuals being unable to afford purchasing them, and b) as previously noted, housing associations avoiding the purchase of new developments from builders due to perceived quality issues.
I'll look into it...stay tuned.
What I’ve been reading
As always, Sarah O'Connor's article in the Financial Times is essential reading. In the most recent issue, she examines how Spain's unemployment rate—once extremely high—has now aligned with Finland's—which was once remarkably low—at approximately 10 percent. Sarah explores the causes behind this shift, but what caught my attention was her mention of immigration as a key driver in both Spain's decline in unemployment and Finland's increase, which is an area we've been covering in this newsletter lately. Be sure to check it out.
read
.